Thanksgiving Leftovers Pizza
Recipe by Chef Tim Lopez
Put your Witt Pizza Oven to work after the holiday feast, with this high-heat showstopper that transforms Thanksgiving leftovers into a gourmet celebration pizza.
These toppings are carefully balanced to prevent the dreaded “soggy center”. Rich savory gravy and tart cranberry sauce create a thick, cohesive base that holds up under heat. Instead of a heavy layer of shredded cheese, this pizza features creamy mashed potatoes placed across the dough. Sliced roasted turkey and tender vegetables blister beautifully under the flame, adding vibrant color and balancing the pizza’s richness.
The result is a flavorful, crowd-pleasing pizza with minimal prep and easy cleanup.

Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: Approximately 2 minutes
Servings: 1 (14-inch pizza)
Ingredients
For the cranberry-gravy base:
- cup thick leftover turkey gravy (save an additional ¼ cup for drizzling)
- 2 tbsp whole-berry cranberry sauce
For the pizza assembly:
- 12 oz. pizza dough ball
- ½ cup leftover mashed potatoes, spooned into dollops
- ½ cup low-moisture, whole-milk mozzarella cheese, shredded
- 3–5 oz. leftover roasted turkey, sliced thin or torn into bite sized pieces, blotted dry
- *Any 2 leftover vegetables you would like to use from your Thanksgiving table, cut into very
- small pieces – roughly ¼ cup
- 2 Tbsp rough chopped Italian/flat-leaf parsley
- Extra virgin olive oil, for tossing vegetables
- Semolina flour, for stretching and launching
*outside of green bean casserole, which I do not recommend putting as a pizza topping as it will most assuredly burn
Instructions
Topping Temp Check: CRITICAL STEP
Ensure dough and all prepared toppings (gravy base, mozzarella, turkey, vegetables, and
mashed potatoes) are verified at room temperature before assembling. Cold ingredients act as
a heat sink, dragging down stone temperature and leaving you with undercooked toppings.
1. Preheat the Oven: Connect the gas to your Witt ETNA Rotante 16” pizza oven. Light
both the main U-burner and the under-stone booster burner. Turn the main flame dial to
high, turn on the 360° stone rotation feature, and preheat the oven for 15 to 20 minutes
until the center of the rotating stone reaches between 750°F and 800°F.
2. Prep the Base & Toppings: In a small bowl, briskly stir together the thick turkey gravy
and cranberry sauce until thoroughly combined, then set aside.
In another small bowl, toss your chosen vegetables together with a little bit of olive oil.
Ensure your sliced turkey is dry and ready for assembly.
3. Stretch and Build: Generously dust your prep station and your pizza peel with semolina
flour. Stretch the dough ball out to a 14-inch round, keeping the edges slightly thicker for
the crust. Carefully transfer the stretched dough directly onto the prepared peel.
4. Assemble: Spread a thin, even layer of the cranberry-gravy base over the dough (put
the thinnest amount in the center) leaving a 1-inch border for crust. Arrange the
vegetables first uniformly over the sauce, then add dollops of the mashed potatoes,
spaced evenly on the pizza and filling the open areas between toppings. Last, arrange
the pieces of roast turkey between the dollops of mashed potatoes. Lightly scatter the
mozzarella around and slightly over the mashed potatoes.
5. Flame Management (Pre-Bake): Ensure the stone rotation on your Witt oven is ON. 5
to 10 seconds BEFORE launching, turn the main U-burner flame dial down to Low (or its
lowest micro-setting). Keep the under-stone booster burner running on High. This
prevents the harsh dome heat from flash-burning the crust, while allowing the bottom
stone heat to cook the pizza from the base up.
6. The Bake: Launch the pizza directly onto the center of the rotating stone. (If preferred,
switch the rotation off, launch the pizza, and immediately turn the rotation back on).
Allow the pizza to bake on low top heat for roughly 90 seconds, giving the dense
leftovers a head start to thoroughly heat and melt the cheese.
7. The Finishing Flare: For the final 15 to 25 seconds of the bake, crank the main U-
burner dial back up to High. This acts like a broiler flame on the rotating pie, rapidly
creating beautiful browning on the crust, lightly roasting the vegetables and sliced turkey
edges, and caramelizing the ridges of the mashed potatoes.
8. Finish and Serve: Slide your pizza peel under the baked pizza to remove it from the
oven and place it onto a cutting board. Immediately scatter the chopped parsley across
the fresh pie and drizzle the reserved gravy with a spoon in thin ribbons over the top. Let
the pizza rest for a minute or two to allow the components to set. Slice it into pieces and
serve warm.


